The Victorian Bar Home
HOME
Francis Charles Francis AM RFD QC
Opas Philip Opas AM OBE QC
Gaynor Judge Liz Gaynor
Bourke Brian Bourke
S.E.K. Hulme QC S.E.K. Hulme AM QC
raising_the_bar Raising The Bar
For the Defence nav image "For the Defence"
speaker icon Four Judges & a Silk (audio)
WBA Logo "Even It Up"
WBA Logo First 25 women barristers slideshow
John Coldrey QC John Coldrey QC
JV Barry JV Barry - book launch slideshow
Peter O’Callaghan QC Peter O’Callaghan QC
Francis Xavier (Frank) Costigan QC Francis Xavier (Frank) Costigan QC
Jeff Sher QC Jeff Sher QC
Profile: Brian Bourke Back
Transcript
On not taking silk

Brian Bourke interview 10 October 2005


But I think now that the ambition of the Bar has been superseded by avidity, I think we just have succumbed to greed. I don't believe in the principle of silk, I'm so Irish that I don't believe in it and I don't know why people claw to do it now. You'll find there'll be 180 applications, I suppose, for silk this year and Marilyn Warren will have to give it to 10 or 12 of them.

Apart from a philosophical objection to it, I've never liked working with other barristers. Frank Vincent was junior to me once, and Colin Lovitt, a pretty distinguished bloke at the Bar now, good bloke good mate of mine. He was junior to me a couple of time in murder trials but I always liked to do things my way. I was sort of bred to be independent, my father treated me as a brother rather than a son and I just don't like working with other people. I had Mandy Fox as a junior in a murder trial we did over here a couple of years ago, but that was just to read a welter of transcripts and all that sort of stuff. I'm not reflecting on her, she's a capable barrister, but I never wanted to be a silk.

What do you think has brought about this avidity as you describe it?

At the Bar?

Yes.

Oh, I think the money now that silks get paid is bordering on obscene. I think we're all grossly overpaid, but some of these people now - they're in receipt of incomes that are not warranted or justified. I think the development of the commercial world to such a degree where commercial barristers are in such demand that huge fees could be chargedŠ I'm not suggesting that a fellow like Myers is not worth every cent that he gets. He is an outstanding individual - he's left the Bar now - but people just latch on to it. I think you'd find at the Bar now there's a lot of silks who are not earning much because there's too many. There's a section of the silks here who are silks for some social reason they might perceive to be important.


Conducted for the Bar Oral History project by Juliette Brodsky in Owen Dixon Chambers East and filmed by Stewart Carter (People Pictures)

 

 
   
© The Victorian Bar Inc - Reg No. A00343046 | Privacy | Contact us | Help | Acknowledgments