The Victorian Bar Home
HOME
Francis Charles Francis AM RFD QC
Opas Philip Opas AM OBE QC
Gaynor Judge Liz Gaynor
Bourke Brian Bourke
S.E.K. Hulme QC S.E.K. Hulme AM QC
raising_the_bar Raising The Bar
For the Defence nav image "For the Defence"
speaker icon Four Judges & a Silk (audio)
WBA Logo "Even It Up"
WBA Logo First 25 women barristers slideshow
John Coldrey QC John Coldrey QC
JV Barry JV Barry - book launch slideshow
Peter O’Callaghan QC Peter O’Callaghan QC
Francis Xavier (Frank) Costigan QC Francis Xavier (Frank) Costigan QC
Jeff Sher QC Jeff Sher QC
  Back  
Transcript - Four Judges and a Silk Part 6
THE MOUSE IN THE BOTTLE

Juliette Brodsky

John Batt, how did all this contrast with Sir Ninian Stephen with whom you read?

John Batt

Well, I was with him for over six months, I think it was approaching nine months, during which time he went away three times. Once to the Privy Council on a tax case. Once to Canada on the newsprint, I think it was, a newsprint arbitration, and once to the United States for an oil company case, which might have been a tax case. I don’t think he would claim to have been an extremely learned person, but he had the ability to get the court on his side by his manner. He was a very busy junior, junior often to Young and Aickin, who deferred taking silk for a while, I think. I enjoyed my time with him and learned much from him, and before I moved out, somebody else moved in, so there were two – I think it was John Monahan - so we overlapped.

Juliette Brodsky

Did his style influence yours?

John Batt

I doubt it, I think I’ve got my own style for what it’s worth.

JD Phillips

By the time you were with him, wasn’t he pretty well a permanent junior?

John Batt

Yes, well very often.

JD Phillips

As I recall, he rarely appeared on his own, so when you talk about style, he was sitting there quietly next door to the silk.

John Batt:

But he’d come in in the morning with a lot of advisory work … a number of things for Miss Davis to type.

JD Phillips

But he was a junior, pretty well a permanent junior.

Bill Ormiston

And the combination of Aickin and Stephen was well known for many years wasn’t it? Big cases, constitutional, companies.

JD Phillips

Oil companies, yes.

Bill Ormiston

Heavy commercial.

James Merralls

He didn’t do too much constitutional work, it was mainly commercial work. When we came to the Bar, people tended to divide the Bar into two categories, common law or equity. He didn’t fall into either. He was what would now be known as a commercial lawyer. I think the QC at that time who would have fallen into that category was George Lush whom we haven’t mentioned. He was neither a common lawyer who did jury work nor a regular wills and trusts, settlement type equity lawyer. But he did company law and contract law, commercial cases.

Clive Tadgell

He did all sorts of things, George (Lush) did. He once led me in a Health Act prosecution. We were briefed for Coca Cola, prosecuted for having a mouse in a bottle of Coca Cola which was sold to a tram conductor, and we lost it.

Juliette Brodsky

How did you lose it - on what basis?

Clive Tadgell

We were for Coca Cola, but the mouse was said to be in the bottle when the tram conductor opened it up and saw these bright eyes beaming into his face, which was a whole lot of nonsense because Coca Cola is so corrosive. To think that the mouse had bright eyes shining up at the tram conductor was so much hogwash, but the magistrate swallowed it, as it were.

John Batt

There used to be a lot of …

Juliette Brodsky

Sorry, may I ask this; did the case ever acquire the same folklore status as the snail in the bottle?

Clive Tadgell

Well it deserved it. It actually happened though, whereas the snail in the bottle might not have happened.

Juliette Brodsky

Sorry, John?

John Batt

I was going to say there were a lot of Health Act prosecutions in those days over meat pies and you had to divide - the sample had to be divided into three parts and that led to a lot of complicated submissions, and principally by Garth Buckner in the Magistrates’ Court.

James Merralls

We had a good friend, Garth Buckner, who specialised in these things.

John Batt

Yes, he was Stephen’s second reader after Shaw.

James Merralls

And he was well known for devising technical defences to Health Act prosecutions.

John Batt

Could I speak of some of the other leaders of the Bar?

Juliette Brodsky

Oh yes, absolutely.

JD Phillips

I learned a very good lesson from George Lush. Whenever I worked with George, I was in awe of him, a great admirer of his but he was a lot my senior and I was surprised to hear him say one day as we crossed William Street as we walked towards the court, he said, “I hope you know what this case is all about because I haven’t got the faintest idea”, and it taught me the lesson that the nerves do get to you no matter how senior you are and as you approach the court, they get stronger. It was good learning early on.

Juliette Brodsky

Actually, just on that point before we move on to some of the other leaders that you would like to discuss, I did speak to a judge recently who said that many of her colleagues suffer from nerves, this adrenalin rush she speaks of, and that some people actually – and I don’t want to get too graphic – do actually get quite sick on the morning of cases and things. Just out of interest, were any of you particularly susceptible to those sort of nerves?

Bill Ormiston

Yes.

John Batt

I think always just before 10.30 you got stirred up, particularly if there were negotiations going on, you’re trying to concentrate on the case and discussing figures at the same time.

JD Phillips

Don’t they say the man who’s never frightened has no imagination?

Juliette Brodsky

Have you ever encountered any who weren’t frightened?

JD Phillips

We all had lots of imagination.

James Merralls

Sir Douglas Menzies told me he used to get into a lather of sweat before he addressed the court.

JD Phillips

When he came off the court after being sworn in, I was told by his staff that his clothes were just all soaked, and that was to be sworn in as a High Court judge.

John Batt

Others may disagree, but the one person I wouldn’t say this of was Ninian Stephen, I thought he looked very relaxed at approaching …

James Merralls

Relaxed and urbane.

Bill Ormiston

But he did have a capacity for picking things up extraordinarily quickly. I had a brief when I was junior to him – must have been the early 70s because he went on the Supreme Court first in ’71 or ’72 first, didn’t he? But it was a landlord and tenant matter, quite a complex one. I’d spent the day looking at these papers and Ninian said, “Well, I can’t look at these papers until tonight and I’ve got a conference at home from 6 to half past 7”, and he said, “You’d better give me three quarters of an hour and we’ll start at…” – yes, it was going to be a quarter past 9 because he was going to have dinner in between. He had grasped all this material far better than I had in that three quarters of an hour that he had available to read the papers and I was staggered, you know.

Juliette Brodsky

A photographic memory, do you think?

Bill Ormiston

Well he probably had a photographic memory, but he had this capacity to read and absorb things so quickly, which I certainly didn’t.

James Merralls

Yes, he was a very intelligent man. I didn’t think he knew very much, but he was a very intelligent man.


 
   
© The Victorian Bar Inc - Reg No. A00343046 | Privacy | Contact us | Help | Acknowledgments